Skip to main content

Teaching Students to Think Critically: Evaluating Media Sources in Middle School

I don’t know about you, but I’ve noticed that my students live in a world where news doesn’t just come from the evening broadcast or the front page of a newspaper. Instead, it comes through TikTok videos, Instagram posts, YouTube clips, and memes shared at lightning speed. And while our students are more connected than ever, that doesn’t mean they’re better at figuring out what’s real, what’s biased, and what’s flat-out fake.

That’s why I make a point of teaching media literacy in my classroom.



Why Media Literacy Matters

We’ve all seen how quickly misinformation can spread, whether it’s a miscaptioned photo, a sensationalized headline, or a “news” story that turns out to be satire. For students, who may not yet have the critical thinking tools to question their sources, this can be overwhelming.

When I introduce media literacy, I don’t frame it as “don’t believe anything you see online.” Instead, I teach students how to ask better questions:

  • Where is this information coming from?

  • What’s the purpose of this article or post?

  • Could bias or sensationalism be shaping how the story is told?

The goal is to empower them to navigate today’s information-rich world with a critical eye.

How I Make It Engaging

Middle schoolers love debate and discovery, so I try to build that into our lessons. Here are a few strategies that have worked for me:
  • Headline Rankings: Students look at a set of headlines and rank them from most to least “newsworthy,” then defend their choices. It sparks lively discussions about timeliness, human interest, and impact.
  • Comparing Coverage: Students read two versions of the same news story from different outlets and ask: What’s different? Who seems more neutral? Why might that be?
  • Spotting Loaded Words: We analyze how words like “heroic,” “shocking,” or “outraged” can completely change the way readers interpret a story.
These activities don’t just teach critical thinking, they also make students realize how powerful language and perspective can be.

Building Habits for a Lifetime

I tell my students that evaluating sources isn’t just about passing a unit test, it’s a skill they’ll need for the rest of their lives. Whether they’re scrolling through social media, reading about a world event, or researching for a school project, I want them to pause and think: Is this source trustworthy?

The more we give them structured practice, the more confident they become in spotting bias, misinformation, and unreliable sources.

A Classroom-Ready Resource

If you’re looking to dig into this topic with your own students, I’ve created an Evaluating Media Sources Unit that’s ready to go. It includes:

  • Engaging activities like headline ranking, media comparisons, and fake news analysis

  • Scaffolded lessons on bias, propaganda, clickbait, and press freedom

  • A summative assessment to bring it all together

If you teach in BC, this is also aligned with the British Columbia Grade 6 Social Studies curriculum!

Teaching media literacy isn’t about making students cynical, it’s about helping them become thoughtful, informed, and empowered citizens.

How do you like to teach this important concept? Let me know in the comments below!



Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rebus Puzzles = So Much Fun!

It's been another wet and rainy Saturday in Victoria, so I spent the morning with brainteasers!  (I know, I'm a total nerd!)  When I was in school, I used to love rebus puzzles.   What are rebus puzzles?  They are word puzzles that illustrate a familiar phrase or saying.  I didn't know until today that they were called Rebus, but now that I know, I want to use the name as much as possible!   I found a couple online, then I decided to make some handouts for my English classes to use as a warm up.  While I was making them, I thought to myself, "Self, this would make a great TpT item!"  I created 36 pages of these brainteasing puzzles, one for each week of a school year, and bundled them up.  They are for sale at my TpT store, One Teacher's Adventures. If you are as nerdy as I am on a rainy Saturday, perhaps you'd like to try some out? See if you can solve these puzzles! For the answers, click here . To buy the packa...
2 comments
Read more

Using Disney's "Inside Out" With Middle Schoolers

I love Disney movies!  My first memory of going to see a movie in the theatre was with my mom and sister when I was about 3 to see The Little Mermaid.  Since then, I've been hooked.  I still go to see Disney movies with my sister when they come out in the theatre, but now we also take her 5-year old son (most of the time). When I saw "Inside Out" this summer, I loved it!  It takes place inside the brain of an 11-year-old girl named Riley.  The main characters are Riley's emotions - Joy, Sadness, Fear, Disgust, and Anger.  The emotions interact with each other and steer Riley through her days, creating memories.  Riley's core memories (important times in her life) create aspects of her personality as Personality Islands.  Riley's 5 main personality islands are Goofball Island, Family Island, Friends Island, Hockey Island, and Honesty Island. When Riley was young, Joy was steering most of her actions, but in the course of the movie, Riley's f...
4 comments
Read more

Personal Coat Of Arms

My Grade 8's have been studying the Medieval Period in Social Studies.  As we were looking at the Magna Carta, several students asked about the Coats of Arms around the outside of the document.  They were quite interested in them, so we ended up researching the Coat of Arms of our school's namesake.  That's when I decided to have my students create one of their own. Several students researched their own family crest and used symbols and images they found from their ancestors.  Others included pictures of things that were important to them. For the assignment, I asked them to include at least 4 symbols that represent themselves in some way.  In addition to the Coat of Arms, they needed to include a write-up explaining the significance of each image. I think next year I will use this activity as a beginning of the year "get to know you" activity.  It can easily be adapted to fit any grade.  Even Kindergarten students could draw pictures and talk...
5 comments
Read more